The Ones That Got Away Walkthrough
In Goofy's first "A Rift in Time" expansion Quest in Disney Dreamlight Valley, "Give Me A Sign," the cheerful Villager happily opened up his first Stall on Eternity Isle. Once you have completed that Quest, you can unlock "The Ones That Got Away," which introduces you to some of Eternity Isle's many new fish and seafood options.
Catch The Fish Goofy Is Missing
Talk to Goofy to learn that he was engaging in his favorite hobby, fishing, in the new Eternity Isle location - but there were several rare fish he was not able to catch. He asks you to catch them instead so that he can learn how to from you. You will need to use your Royal Fishing Rod to catch the following fish:
- 2 x Robot Fish - Caught from orange bubbling spots in the Docks and Overlook areas of Ancients' Landing.
- 2 x Dunebopper - Caught from white or blue bubbling spots in the Oasis area of the Glittering Dunes. Unlocking this area requires 6000 Mist. You can earn Mist by completing Mist Duties or Timebending or clearing Swirling Sands using your Royal Hourglass.
- 2 x Prisma Shrimp - Caught from orange bubbling spots in the Grove area of the Wild Tangle. Unlocking this area requires 4000 Mist. You will need to unlock this area as part of either Rapunzel's Quest "The Tower" or Gaston's Quest "The Wild Tangle's Swarm."
You can increase the rate of rare fish, such as Robot Fish and Prisma Shrimp, appearing by crafting and using a Miracle Fishing Bait or Even More Miraculous Fishing Bait.
Cook Meals Using Eternity Isle Fish
Once you've caught all six fish, give them to Goofy. He then decides he wants to try some recipes made from the fish, and lets you keep one of each kind. He also gives you a "Crate Full O'Fish" containing Paprika, Celery, Rice, and Butter.
To complete this step, you simply need to make any recipe that uses either Robot Fish, Dunebopper, or Prisma Shrimp. You can talk to Remy to get some advice about what to make.
The little chef will suggest combining the Celery, Butter, Rice and Paprika Goofy gave you with one Prisma Shrimp to make "Blend of the Bayou." However, there are several other Meals you can also cook to fulfill this Quest. Some options include:
- Best Fish Forever - Celery, Cumin, Robot Fish, and Sea Snail
- Nuts & Bolts - Almond, Robot Fish
- Sand Stew - Any Spice, Any Vegetable, Dunebopper, Sand Fish, Sandworm
- Rainbouillabaisse - Any Seafood, Any Vegetable, Prisma Shrimp, Rainbow Trout, Tomato
Talk to Goofy about the meal you just made. He reveals that he was trying out some cooking of his own, and gives you his creation: a Mooncake. This brings the Quest "The Ones That Got Away" to a conclusion, and leaves Goofy happily catching all of the new fish on Eternity Isle!